OK to believe in the word of an infallible god? OK

Canada Goose online pedals religion again in the NYT Canada Goose online

canada goose clearance Although she may not be a believer, when she writes about religionshe is devoted to explaining why faith is good or useful. When she says anything else, it mundane. Luhrmann attended one of the many all night in Accra, much of which involved excoriating canada goose outlet las vegas demons, which those in attendance consider canada goose outlet ottawa real. (Luhmann adds the frightening statistic that 57% of Americans also believe in demons.) canada goose clearance

canada goose uk black friday (By the way, if one included sub Saharan African countries like Ghana in the worldwide positive correlation between religiosity and social dysfunctionality, the correlation would be even more striking, for sub Saharan countries are both highly religious and highly dysfunctional.) canada goose uk black friday

Canada Goose Coats On Sale Luhrmann title should have been demons seem real, but of course she doesn want to judge them as illusory. She is, after all, an anthropologist, and it presumably not kosher to pass judgment on such things. And besides, belief in demons serves a useful purpose (Luhrmann is always to point out the utility of faith). Canada Goose Coats On Sale

uk canada goose outlet J. Kwabena Asamoah Gyadu, a professor at Trinity Theological Seminary in Legon, Ghana, argues that these churches have spread so rapidly because African traditional religion canada goose uk envisions a world dense with dark spirits from which people must protect themselves, and these new churchestake this evil seriouslyin a way that many earlier missionizing Christianities did not. Indeed, I have been at a Christian service in Accra with thousands of people shouting: “The witches will die! They will die! Die! Die!” With the pastor roaring, “This canada goose outlet store new york is a war zone!” uk canada goose outlet

canadian goose jacket Most of us know what this has resulted in: horrible killings, expulsion of children from homes, and so on, but Luhrmann barely mentions this. All she says is this: canadian goose jacket

canada goose black friday sale But it is also true that an external agent gives you something and often, someone to identify as nonhuman. In West Africa,witches are people, and sometimes, other people kill them or drive them from their canada goose outlet seattle homes. canada goose black friday sale

buy canada goose jacket cheap Yes, other people canada goose vest outlet kill them or drive them from their homes. This is about as much of a downside as Lurhmann can muster (the other downsides of African Pentecostal Christianity include helping spread HIV and AIDS by urging the afflicted to go off their drugs, for God will cure them, and, in the past, encouraging the genocide in Rwanda). buy canada goose jacket cheap

Luhrmann goes on, helpfully, canada goose outlet mall to tell us how demons can be useful even if we don canada goose outlet online store believe that they real. The following lame discussion is unworthy of an undergraduate paper, much less a column by a professional anthropologist.. One way to think about demons (if you happen not to believe in supernatural evil) is that they are a way of representing human hatred, rage and failure the stuff we all canada goose outlet miami set out to exorcize in our New Year’s resolutions. from the University of Washington and, eventually, a job at Princeton, canada goose outlet in toronto once remarked that all humans deal with demons. (He was quoting Dostoyevsky’s “Brothers Karamazov” “In every man, of course, a demon lies hidden.”) The only question, he said, was whether the demons were located in the mind, where Freud placed them, or in the world. It is possible that identifying your envy as external and alien canada goose clothing uk makes it easier to quell.

Do Luhrmann or Obeyeskere really think that the presence canada goose outlet in uk of real demons in the world is canada goose outlet los angeles a viable question?

cheap canada goose uk Finally, after downplaying the hundreds of murders and child expulsions done under a false belief in demons, Luhrmann raises what she sees as the really serious problems of such belief: cheap canada goose uk

cheap Canada Goose In an April poll conducted by Public Policy Polling, over one in 10 Americans were confident that Barack Obamawas the Antichrist and the Antichrist is, as it happens, associated with war in the Middle East. If those people think that demons are real, they don’t mean that Obama is misguided, confused or mistaken. They mean that he is real, inhuman evil. cheap Canada Goose

If those people think that demons are real. We don know that, but Luhrmann makes the assumption. But I seriously doubt that more than 10% of American think that Obama is This is simply a lame segue between African demons and the President, a way to say something when you have nothing to canada goose outlet hong kong say.

Canada Goose Online But at last we have an editorial comment by anthropologist Luhrmann! How terrifying it is that 10% of canada goose outlet American think that Obama is the http://www.canadagoosejacketoutlett.com Antichrist! If the murder of large groups of Africans is as terrifying as Obama demonization, Luhrmann doesn tell us; she says onl that y other people kill them or drive them from their homes is writing and thinking at its most mundane. Luhrmann analysis is superficial and her writing wooden. There is nothing in her piece that makes youthink, and that because she really has nothing to say. border? Canada Goose Online

canada goose store The commenters on Lurhmann piece are in fact much savvier than canada goose outlet edmonton she is. Many of them point out the connection between poverty and superstition; even more note that demon belief is one of the great evils of modern religion. canada goose store

canada goose factory sale It hard for me to canada goose outlet online reviews take this op ed seriously when Ms. Lurhman [sic] barely mentions how are people and yet fails to acknowledge that there is a serious problem with children being called witches, forced out of their families and communities and sometimes even killed. This is not canada goose outlet canada a small problem. BBC 3 broadcast a documentary last May called a Witch and noted there are thousands of children kicked out of their homes because they were labeled a witch by these religious deliverance specialists. And canada goose outlet vancouver it spreading into the United Kingdom and the USA. Witchfinder General Helen Ukpabio of Nigeria was supposed to spread her gospel of rooting out the witches in Houston in early 2012, but there was some canada goose jacket outlet toronto controversy and no idea whether she actually made it canada goose outlet jackets there. But this stuff is HERE and children are suffering. Why did you not mention it, Ms. Luhrman? canada goose factory sale

I wish we could focus more on the sources of fear and desperation that empower such hate creating, demonizing religion. Even discussing demons and evangelical tribalism in isolation, as this article does, only further empowers it by adding to our irrational fear of the irrational. If you want to draw attention to hate mongering religiosity, then please mention (at least) the societal conditions that drive people to demonize each other as an act of survival: ideological politics; a growing awareness of inequality through global connectedness; dwindling resources for canada goose outlet buffalo an ever increasing population; etc.

uk canada goose Organized religion can be a source of community and comfort, but can also provide justification for the oldest solution to society problems: tribal warfare. To evoke the emotional fear without also canada goose kensington parka uk evoking the rational mind only makes the situation worse. uk canada goose

Canada Goose Parka Luhrmann religious/superstitious bias makes it impossible for her to be objective. For example, when she says: say that the boundary between the supernatural and the natural is thinner there she assumes that there exists a supernatural, and that its qualities can be measured and debated. Canada Goose Parka

canada goose clearance sale Is this the sort of medieval thinking that the NYT wants to promote? canada goose clearance sale

All religious beliefs and behaviors are based on irrational superstition, despite Luhrmann efforts to convince us otherwise.

canada goose coats She rationalizes the beliefs or behaviors she encounters in order (it seems) to minimize their ridiculousness and align them more closely with Western Christian sensibilities. But when canada goose outlet location we lend credence to irrational beliefs, we also endorse the irrational behaviors they engender, and some of these are destructive. Is it OK to believe in demons? Sure, pray all night if you want. OK to believe in witches? No, because some people kill canada goose factory outlet even children. OK to believe in the word of an infallible god? OK, because the god says shalt not kill, OK to believe in an infallible god? No, because the god says your child if he curses you. Who decides what is OK or not OK? Luhrmann? canada goose coats

Why has this series of essays of which offer broad conclusions drawn canada goose outlet uk only from anecdotal observations Even as opinion canada goose outlet 80 off pieces, this series is not worthy of the NYT and its readers. Discuss religion? Yes, and with vigor! But surely we can do so with more depth and substance.